Three Corn Casserole

Part corn bread, part corn pudding this Three Corn Casserole with Jiffy corn muffin mix has simple ingredients and makes a great side dish!

This moist corn casserole is requested at Thanksgiving, Christmas, Easter and other special family meals throughout the year.

Three Corn Casserole Recipe

A familiar corn bread recipe that is mellowed out by 6 ingredients makes a delicious Three Corn Casserole! Just mix a can of whole corn, creamed corn, sour cream, butter, egg and a box of Jiffy mix together. This recipe is so easy I mix by hand, no electric mixer is necessary!

Totally homemade our Amish Style Scalloped Corn Casserole has Swiss cheese and a homestyle flavor. My mom has always made this Jiffy Corn Pudding. I think this new favorite recipe is a blend of the those two baked corn casseroles.

I recently went on a trip and got this recipe from the best of a church ladies cookbook. Those are the recipes I always have to try! I found our most popular Jiffy Broccoli Cornbread and Old Fashioned Cornbread Dressing in the favorites section of other vintage community cookbooks.

Thick Pieces Vs. Thin Pieces

The original recipe calls for a 2 quart casserole dish. I tested the recipe in a square 8″ x 8″ baking dish. This casserole was very thick and took a full hour to bake. The edges tasted more like a firm corn bread and the center still had more of a corn pudding texture.

In our family the thinner pieces with more consistent texture is our preference. A 9 x 13″ dish also bakes in about 45 minutes in a convection oven.

I think thinner casseroles are easier to get baked, but personal preference will help make the decision.

Ingredients Needed

• Butter – adds a rich flavor
• Sour Cream – makes every tender so moist and delicious
• Egg – helps provide structure, allows the batter to rise a bit as it expands while cooking and adds flavor
• Whole Kernel Corn – the pieces or kernels that you see in every bite so your eyes know you’re enjoying corn casserole
• Can of Creamed Corn – brings all the creamy, corny goodness that you expect at a special meal
• Box of Jiffy Corn Muffin Mix – gives the corn bread base and structure you hope for in a corn casserole

Should Corn Casserole Be Covered When Baking?

When the corn casserole is 1 1/2″ thick or less I typically bake uncovered because the entire casserole can bake evenly.

A thicker casserole that is 2″ or thicker should be covered for at least the first half of the baking time. Covering the dish will prevent the top and sides from burning before the center is set.

How to Make Corn and Cornbread Casserole

In a medium sized mixing bowl add softened or partially melted butter, an egg and sour cream.

Use a wooden spoon to stir it all together. Ensure the egg is beaten and mixed in well in this step.

This mixture will be very creamy!

Next drain the can of whole corn that is in clear liquid. Pour it into the mixture.

Add the can of cream of corn to the bowl as well.

I have a set of small silicone spatulas that are perfect for cleaning out the cans easily.

Mix well. The batter is really shaping up now!

Finally add one small box of Jiffy corn muffin mix and stir well.

Pour into a lightly greased 9 x 13″ baking dish and bake in a 375°F for about 45 minutes until golden brown and set. Casserole is set when it doesn’t jiggle much when given a light shake. A toothpick inserted in the center will come out mostly clean.

Recipe Tips & Tricks

• There are different types of whole kernel corn, it doesn’t matter if the kernels are white, yellow or a blend.
• Remember to drain the whole kernel corn, otherwise the casserole can be very hard to finish baking all the way through in the center.
• Butter should be softened enough to stir easily by hand, but try to avoid completely melting.
• These mini silicone spatulas make recipes like this so much easier and help decrease food waste in the cans.

More Great Holiday Side Dish Recipes:

California Blend Vegetable Medley is a great vegetable casserole with cheese and French fried onions on top!

Zucchini Casserole has stuffing mix on top of really creamy slices of softened zucchini.

Make Ahead Crock Pot Mashed Potatoes is a great way to save time and stress during a big holiday!

Grandma’s Old-Fashioned Dressing is so smooth even people who don’t think they love dressing enjoy it.

Crock Pot Mac & Cheese is perfect for all ages at fancy holiday meals and casual weeknight dinners.

Printable 3 Corn Casserole Recipe