Old Fashioned Cream Pie

A rich and creamy pudding baked in a pie shell makes this memorable Old Fashioned Cream Pie recipe so good!

Close up piece of rich and creamy old fashioned sugar cream pie with a browned layer on top from baking and a crimped pie crust sticking up in the back and a fork leaning on the plate.

Old Fashioned Cream Pie Recipe

This enchanting mixture tastes like rich whipping cream and a sugar mixture got married. Then they had a sweet, creamy baby that baked to beautiful perfection before arriving at the dessert table. 

Don’t feel intimidated to make this old fashion pie recipe. It’s got a much better chance of turning out great than you might think!

While there are several variations of this vintage recipe ours is the easiest and takes very little effort to make. This recipe is from the same era as our enjoyable Cottage Cheese Cookies and Rhubarb Crunch.

Old fashioned cream pie is also known as Sugar Cream Pie and Hoosier Sugar Pie, this gem is the state pie of Indiana.

Save this Recipe
Please enable JavaScript in your browser to complete this form.

Enter your email and I’ll send this recipe right to your inbox! Plus, I’ll send you new recipes every week!

Pie server lifting a piece of delicious old fashioned cream pie above the full pie.

My husband worked in a grain purchasing office on the Ohio and Indiana state line. On each person’s birthday they got to choose a dessert. A few people enjoy requesting this special Old Fashioned Cream Pie recipe.

He always enjoyed this even though his personal favorite birthday desserts are these Cake Mix Cupcakes and Cherry Cheesecake.

Why This Recipe Works:

  • Great pie to begin with if you want to make a baked pie.
  • An old-fashioned recipe with a smooth and creamy taste that is still enjoyable.
  • This pie recipe brings back memories of the past for many older people and creates a great conversation piece.
  • Has a unique look and enjoyable creamy flavor and calls for simple ingredients.
Slice of old fashion cream pie on a stack of white plates with a brown top and the whole pie in the background.

Ingredients Needed

  • Unbaked pie shell
  • Heavy whipping cream
  • Half and half
  • Butter
  • Cornstarch
  • Granulated sugar
  • Cinnamon – optional
Ingredients to make old fashioned cream pie are a pie crust, cornstarch, sugar, butter, half & half, and heavy whipping cream on a white counter top.

What Thickens A Cream Pie?

Cornstarch thickens this cream pie and helps the center filling firm up while baking.

Preparing the Pie Crust.

Line a 9″ pie plate with a prepared pie crust. I like to use a refrigerated store bought crust.

Fold the edges under and pinch or crimp the edges of the pie crust to look attractive.

Don’t worry about perfecting the crust. Focus on making some progress as the only way to improve the look of a crust is to make them several times.

Refrigerated pie crust unrolled in a 9" pie plate with the edge folded under and part of the crust beginning to be crimped.

Do NOT bake the crust before filling.

How To Make An Old Fashioned Sugar Cream Pie

In a pot on the stove pour the heavy whipping cream and half and half in the pan.

Turn to low or medium low heat and stir every couple minutes.

You’ll know the mixture is warm when you can feel it starting to create a layer of film on the bottom of the pan. This is fine, just stir more frequently until the filling is done.

Once the cream is warm cut the butter into a few chunks and add to the warm cream mixture. Or add the whole stick.

A stick of butter melting into heavy whipping cream and half and half in a pot on the stove.

Stir almost continuously until the butter is melted.

In a small bowl mix together the sugar and cornstarch.

Spatula stirring granulated sugar and cornstarch into a cream mixture heating to become and easy sugar cream pie filling.

Turn down to low heat and slowly pour thirds or quarters of the mixture into the cream mixture. Stir until the sugar is dissolved before adding the next portion.

Stir until well mixed. Then turn the heat off and remove the pan from the heat.

Silicone spatula stirring sugar into a warmed heavy whipping cream, half and half and butter in a stock pot.

Continue to stir often for about five minutes to allow the filling to cool just a bit.

Pour the filling into the pie crust. Not all of the filling will fit, but since there are no eggs the extra mixture is safe to eat if you like.

Unbaked pie crust filled with a cooked cream pie filling on a brown counter top.

Bake in a preheated 350℉ for 45 minutes.

The center will get pretty brown and likely create a big bubble in the center.

Brown top on a cream pie with a big bubble in the center as it was just taken out of the oven.

Allow pie to cool to room temperature and the bubble will quickly relax to a flat layer.

Cover with foil and chill in the refrigerator before serving.

Recipe Tips & Tricks

  • Be patient when cooking the filling on the stove, stir often and cook over low or medium low heat.
  • There will be a some extra filling, but not enough to make a second pie.
  • Sprinkle up to 1 teaspoon of cinnamon over the top before baking if desired.
  • The center of the pie will cook and become deep brown and bubble up, this is normal and will taste fine.
  • Dairy tastes better cool than warm when it comes to the creamy ingredients used in this recipe, so serve chilled for best results.
Sugar cream pie in a clear glass pie plate with a quarter of the pie removed to show the smooth and creamy layer on a red and white polka dot napkin.

Notes On Alternatives:

Several other popular cream pie recipes take extra steps that I did not. Our version came from a community cookbook made on the state line of Ohio and Indiana.

  • I did not add cinnamon or place under broil to form a sugar crust on top.
  • I did not bake or poke the pie crust before filling.

More Old-Fashioned Dessert Recipes

Blueberry Crisp has a sweet blueberry layer topped with an oatmeal streusel mixture that is delicious.

Carrot Cake Loaf makes carrot cake in a loaf pan and is topped with a thick layer of cream cheese frosting.

Mandarin Orange Pie is a no-bake twist on a popular cake.

Close up piece of rich and creamy old fashioned cream pie on a pie server.

Old Fashioned Cream Pie

Servings 8 pieces
Author: Jennifer
A rich and creamy pudding baked in a pie shell makes this memorable Old Fashioned Cream Pie recipe so good!
Prep Time 11 minutes
Cook Time 45 minutes
Chill Time 3 hours
Total Time 3 hours 56 minutes

Ingredients
  

  • 1 9 inch pie crust
  • 2 cups granulated sugar
  • 1/2 cup butter
  • 5 tablespoons cornstarch
  • 16 ounces heavy whipping cream
  • 16 ounces half and half

Instructions
 

  • Line a pie plate with an uncooked pie crust. Fold the edges under and create a decorative finish along the top edge of the crust.
  • Pour heavy cream and half and half in a heavy sauce pan. Heat until warm over low to medium low heat. Stir occassionally.
  • Cut butter into slices and add to the cream. Heat until warm and stir occasionally until melted.
  • Mix together sugar and cornstarch. When the cream mixture is warm turn to low heat and slowly add the dry ingredients. Stir constantly until mixed.
  • Remove pan from the heat and continue to stir to prevent sticking to the bottom. Let the mixture sit about 5 minutes before pouring into the unbaked shell.
  • Bake uncovered at 350℉ for 45 minutes. Let cool and then chill before serving.

Notes

  • There will be a some extra filling, but not enough to make a second pie.
  • Sprinkle up to 1 teaspoon of cinnamon over the top before baking if desired.
  • The center of the pie will cook and become deep brown and bubble up, this is normal and will taste fine.
  • Serve chilled for best results.

Nutrition

Calories: 695kcalCarbohydrates: 71gProtein: 5gFat: 45gSaturated Fat: 26gPolyunsaturated Fat: 2gMonounsaturated Fat: 13gTrans Fat: 0.5gCholesterol: 114mgSodium: 244mgPotassium: 158mgFiber: 1gSugar: 54gVitamin A: 1389IUVitamin C: 1mgCalcium: 107mgIron: 1mg

Nutritional Disclaimer

“Plowing Through Life” is not a dietitian or nutrition professional. Any nutritional information shared is an estimate and can vary greatly depending on specific products are used. If calorie count and other nutritional values are important to you, we recommend running the ingredients through an online nutritional calculator of your choice.

Tried this recipe?Mention @PlowingThroughLife or tag #PlowingThroughLife!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating